top of page
  • Writer's pictureJayne Lisbeth

Lives Discovered in a Vermont Cemetery

I obsess over each Food for Thought I write. I take at least two weeks to muse over every word, nuance, and grammatical and spelling error on the horizon. Not this time. I am writing off the cuff of Vermont, in time for All Hallows Eve, Halloween and Dia de las Muertos.

The heart of this story is the ancient Newfane Hill Cemetery in South Newfane, Vermont. It is where my granddaughter discovered the most unusual gravestone I have seen in my fifty-one years of cemetery excursions.

Knowing my history and love of Vermont, my son was my chauffeur. He drove Tim and I and his children down old logging trails, dirt roads, through magnificent fall foliage, nearby lakes, rivers, and small villages. On one back road I noticed a cemetery and screamed, “STOP! Can we visit this cemetery? It looks really old.” Of course, my dear son complied.

We all set forth through the old gate and entered this ancient, sacred place. Rarely had I seen so many pristine gravestones, many in slate. It was as though this site had been protected by the old maples and oaks overhead, their gathering branches preserving this hallowed world below.

We began to investigate, wandering between gravestones in search of the oldest ones. As we walked I shared with my granddaughter my history of gravestone rubbings and instructions on the art of gravestone rubbing. We marveled over the beauty of each discovered stone. I emphasized the intricacy of each stone. They were works of art from weeping willows to angels to sorrow-filled faces to the admonishments of the dead to the living, all etched into stone by artisans. We talked of the wonder of each life lived, memorialized on slate or marble. We mused over life’s instructions one gravestone provided, “As you are now so once was I, prepare for death and follow me.” Sobering thoughts for a ten-year old girl or a seventy-two year old woman.

We discovered one of the oldest gravestones, which captivated us. Hezekiah Taylor died in 1817, and had been educated at “Harvard University, Cambridge, MS.” Imagine that, the grave of a man who had attended the same school, Harvard, where my granddaughter's great-

Grandfather had been a professor and her great-grandmother had infused the love of art, the necessity of art scholarships, endowments and galleries into those vaulted halls of Harvard.

The gravestone we read proclaimed Hezekiah to be an esteemed, well-respected man who had become a pastor of his “own congregation.” Next to his grave was that of Sarah, the “Consort” of Hezekiah.

I was astounded. Consort? Wasn’t that a polite way of saying “mistress?” Although there were no birth dates on either stone, I calculated that they were born the same year, 1751. Sarah had outlived Hezekiah by 23 years. Her last name was not included on her stone, leaving her identity a mystery and open to speculation. Perhaps they were childhood friends, who later became secret lovers? Did they ever marry? Sarah’s story entices me, draws me into her hidden life. I returned to the present with my granddaughter's question, “What’s a consort?”

Webster's Dictionary defines consort as a partner or spouse. I assumed Sarah was not a spouse as her last name was absent from her stone, not entirely unusual. I wondered how much I should reveal to my granddaughter in this age of political correctness. A girlfriend, or the mistress of a well-respected Reverend?’ To be safe, I replied, “A girlfriend or a partner.”

We read the passage on the gravestone together: “SARAH, consort of Rev. Hezekiah Taylor, died March 28, 1840, AE 89 years. This marble was erected by a few female friends as a memorial of her worth and their affection.”

We had discovered the first gravestone erected for a female “consort'' in any cemetery I have ever encountered in my 54 years of gravestone-rubbing history. This was early-world feminism and love. A group of women, “with affection,” wanted to validate Sarah’s life, the consort of their reverend. At her age of death, 89, there would have been few of her peers left to erect a stone for Sarah or those with the funds to do so. Her “few female friends” did, “with affection.”

We backed up to view the stones to a greater advantage and stumbled over another esteemed gentleman’s gravestone, a well-respected attorney, and “Esquire.” Lo and behold, next to his grave was another “consort.” Her gravestone had also been placed by the same group of women as Sarah’s, but with a different epitaph. We searched, but could not find more than those two consorts in the entire cemetery.

We had stumbled onto consorts of history. In this 1750s cemetery, Sarah, Consort of Hezekiah, had been given her value, her worth, by her “few female friends'' who remembered her “with affection.” She had become memorialized in stone. Her female friends were determined not to allow Sarah’s life to be unremembered and unremarked. Sarah would not lose her foothold in their lives and hearts as the years turned over in their graves.

Each life lived is a personal adventure known intimately to those closest to the departed. Only their date of birth, death, occupation is usually etched into their gravestone, along with a favorite verse or admonishment to the living. In family plots, one can identify the children of the departed. The rest of their lives is a mystery, waiting to be revealed. Sarah, consort of Hezekiah, beckons me from her gravestone. Hers is a life I long to discover, to delve into. She is a temptress awakening my imagination, asking me to follow her down the path of her long-forgotten existence.

Each grave visited tempts me with the same love of history and discovery. These cemeteries, cities of stone, remind us of the importance of each life lived, of each personal adventure, triumph or failure. It is up to the living to delve into and provide value to our past. My love of cemeteries and initiating my granddaughter into the beauty, peace and necessity of respecting and preserving our past led to this unexpected discovery in a hidden cemetery, nestled in the Green Mountains of Vermont.

History matters. I am forever immersed in the grace of gravestones and the past. I strive to pass this torch to the next generation of Sarahs.

Until the next page is turned I’ll enjoy researching and will keep you posted on any historical discoveries I encounter. Happy hunting and haunting!

*** To learn more about the history of Newfane, go to: and***

148 views5 comments

Recent Posts

See All


Nov 05, 2021

Lovely piece, dear author! And I love that the girlfriends were the ones who honored her. History DOES matter, and the fact that you spent time in the old cemetery was just a huge gift to read about.

But may I offer this? In the days in which Hezekiah lived and died, "consort" very much meant "wife." Remember the king and queen consorts of history? They were assuredly married partners, often from two massive and major families across continents, and sometimes even distant (and not so distant) cousins. No "girlfriends" there! Reassure your granddaughter that the "consort" of Hezekiah's time (perhaps he loved high-toned language?!) was most probably his legal wife who truly needed no last name, as it wa…

Jayne Lisbeth
Jayne Lisbeth
Nov 05, 2021
Replying to

Yes, of course! Read my latest Good for Thought and update to this to learn of Sarah's identity!


Jayne Lisbeth
Jayne Lisbeth
Oct 17, 2021

thank you so much, Ardis! You are my wonderful faithful reader, and I always enjoy your comments. Today's was so poetic, "walking alongside you, with leaves crackling beneath my feet." So happy you felt as though we were exploring together!


Oct 17, 2021

Beautiful!!! I love old cemeteries. The headstones are so interesting.

Your writing had me walking right alongside you, with leaves crackling beneath my feet.

bottom of page